Claims

Having coverage for a loss is why you have insurance; however, filing a claim is a very important decision. If it is during our regular business hours (9a.m. – 5 p.m. Monday – Friday), PLEASE call our office to discuss the loss. If it is after hours and your situation is an emergency, please contact your specific carrier immediately.

Company Name

Claims Phone Number

Progressive

800-274-4499 800-776-4737 (service)

Safeco

800-332-3226

American Strategic (Progressive Home)

866-274-5677

Stillwater (Fidelity)

800-220-1351

Hartford

800-243-5860

Metlife

800-854-6011

Travelers

800-252-4633

Electric Insurance

800-227-2757

Kemper/Unitrin

888-321-9392

Foremost

800-527-3907

Mercury

866-819-7772

Commerce West

800-244-1545

Mapfre

877-962-7373

King/Integon/Nat’l General

844-273-4197

American Modern

800-375-2075

American Reliable

800-245-1505

Markel

800-245-1505

American Summit

480-991-6312

Scottsdale

McAlister-Gray has been my insurance provider for well over a decade, covering my home(s), auto(s), umbrellas (Did you know you can protect yourself against rain? LOL!). The staff has been great, and I have recommended them to many of my friends and colleagues. David is the only insurance agent that has ever proactively contacted me about changing policies and giving me a lower rate – absolutely amazing.”

Gary M. – Scottsdale
“David is a great guy and a wonderful Insurance Agent! I talked with him and got a quote for both my autos and my homeowners. Since he is an Independent Agent, he was able to check around and get me the best deal. I had both auto and home with the same company for years, but David saved me several hundred dollars with the two policies placing them with two different companies. He got me the coverage I needed and I’m delighted that I made the change to McAlister-Gray! Thanks again, David.”

Tencil S. – Gilbert
I’ve had the pleasure of working with the McAlister-Gray Agency for several years. They have always been very accommodating, helpful and friendly. I would recommend them to anyone!

Gary G. – Gilbert
I had the pleasure of working with Michele Gonzalez when I purchased my second home and was looking for affordable homeowners insurance. She was professional, quick and very knowledgeable and got me a great deal on my policy. I would highly recommend Michele and McAlister-Gray Insurance Agency.

Ruben B. – Casa Grande
Your Agency is always so helpful and courteous, and your employees are great – especially Kim Cox. I called under duress, and she, with her knowledge, was so helpful and put me at ease. She lifted a weight off of my shoulders! Every time I call she is right there showing a sense of urgency to take care of me and my family. You have a great employee there!”

Jamie M. – Glendale